Rulings · Berlin, State of Berlin, Germany
| Date | Observance | Decided by | Standing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fri 5 Jan | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 12 Jan | Putradā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Sat 13 Jan | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 127 of 127 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sun 14 Jan | Bhogi | Kept the day before Pongal. | Determinate |
| Mon 15 Jan | Pongal | The Sun enters Makara after the sunset before this day. | Determinate |
| Mon 15 Jan | Makara Saṅkrānti | The Sun enters Makara on this day, counted from midnight. | Determinate |
| Tue 16 Jan | Mattu Pongal | Kept the day after Pongal. | Determinate |
| Fri 19 Jan | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Sat 27 Jan | Ṣaṭtilā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 29 Jan | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 121 of 121 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Mon 29 Jan | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Tue 30 Jan | Yama Tarpaṇa | Caturdaśī covers 121 of 121 minutes of aruṇodaya. | Determinate |
| Sat 3 Feb | Tila Caturthī | Caturthī covers 119 of 119 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sun 4 Feb | Gaṇeśa Jayantī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 5 Feb | Śrī Pañcamī | Pañcamī does not reach madhyāhna on either day. | Determinate |
| Mon 5 Feb | Vasanta Pañcamī | Pañcamī does not reach madhyāhna on either day. | Determinate |
| Wed 7 Feb | Ratha Saptamī | Saptamī covers 114 of 117 minutes of aruṇodaya. | Boundary |
| Sat 10 Feb | Jayā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Sun 11 Feb | Bhīṣma Dvādaśī | Dvādaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 12 Feb | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 114 of 114 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Wed 14 Feb | Māghī Pūrṇimā | Pūrṇimā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 18 Feb | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 26 Feb | Vijayā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Tue 27 Feb | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 106 of 106 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Wed 28 Feb | Mahāśivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Mon 4 Mar | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 11 Mar | Āmalakī Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Tue 12 Mar | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 98 of 98 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Thu 14 Mar | Holikā Dahana | Pūrṇimā covers 142 of 142 minutes of sāyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 15 Mar | Holī | Kept the day after Holikā Dahana. | Determinate |
| Sat 16 Mar | Vasantotsava | Pratipadā holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 18 Mar | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Sat 23 Mar | Śītalāṣṭamī | Aṣṭamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 26 Mar | Pāpamocanī Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Thu 28 Mar | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 90 of 90 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Thu 28 Mar | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī does not reach niśītha on either day. | Boundary |
| Sun 31 Mar | Navarātrārambha (Caitra) | Pratipadā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 2 Apr | Gaurī Tṛtīyā | Tṛtīyā does not reach madhyāhna on either day. | Determinate |
| Tue 2 Apr | Saubhāgya Śayana Vrata | Tṛtīyā does not reach madhyāhna on either day. | Determinate |
| Tue 2 Apr | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 3 Apr | Lakṣmī Pañcamī | Pañcamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sat 6 Apr | Bhavānī Utpatti | Aṣṭamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 7 Apr | Rāma Navamī | Navamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 9 Apr | Kāmadā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Thu 11 Apr | Anaṅga Trayodaśī | Trayodaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 11 Apr | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 82 of 82 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Fri 12 Apr | Viṣṇudamanaka Caturdaśī | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sat 13 Apr | Vaiśākhī | The Sun enters Meṣa on this day, counted from sunrise. | Determinate |
| Sat 13 Apr | Caitrī Pūrṇimā | Pūrṇimā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 17 Apr | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Thu 25 Apr | Varūthinī Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Fri 26 Apr | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 74 of 74 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 27 Apr | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Tue 30 Apr | Paraśurāma Jayantī | Tṛtīyā does not reach pradoṣa on either day. | Boundary |
| Wed 1 May | Akṣaya Tṛtīyā | Tṛtīyā covers 300 of 300 minutes of pūrvāhṇa. | Determinate |
| Thu 2 May | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 3 May | Śaṅkara Jayantī | Pañcamī does not reach madhyāhna on either day. | Boundary |
| Sat 4 May | Gaṅgotpatti | Saptamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 9 May | Mohinī Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Thu 9 May | Paraśurāma Dvādaśī | Dvādaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 9 May | Rukmiṇī Dvādaśī | Dvādaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 10 May | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 68 of 68 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 11 May | Nṛsiṃha Caturdaśī | Caturdaśī covers 67 of 67 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Mon 13 May | Buddha Pūrṇimā | Pūrṇimā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 13 May | Sampat Gaurī Vrata | Pūrṇimā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 17 May | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Fri 24 May | Aparā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī touches no sunrise; it is kept on the day it falls. | Determinate |
| Sat 25 May | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī does not reach pradoṣa on either day. | Boundary |
| Sun 26 May | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Thu 30 May | Rambhā Tṛtīyā | Tṛtīyā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 31 May | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 2 Jun | Araṇya Gaurī Vrata | Ṣaṣṭhī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 2 Jun | Skanda Ṣaṣṭhī (Jyaiṣṭha) | Ṣaṣṭhī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 7 Jun | Nirjalā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Sat 8 Jun | Śrī Rāma Dvādaśī | Dvādaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 9 Jun | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 58 of 58 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Tue 11 Jun | Vaṭa Sāvitrī Vrata | Pūrṇimā covers 58 of 58 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 15 Jun | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Sun 23 Jun | Yoginī Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 24 Jun | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 58 of 58 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Mon 24 Jun | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī does not reach niśītha on either day. | Boundary |
| Fri 28 Jun | Rathayātrā | Dvitīyā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sat 29 Jun | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 30 Jun | Skanda Pañcamī | Pañcamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 2 Jul | Vivasvat Saptamī | Saptamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 7 Jul | Hariśayanī Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Tue 9 Jul | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 60 of 60 minutes of pradoṣa. | Boundary |
| Thu 11 Jul | Vyāsa Pūjā | Pūrṇimā covers 197 of 197 minutes of the first three muhūrtas after sunrise. | Determinate |
| Thu 11 Jul | Guru Pūrṇimā | Pūrṇimā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 11 Jul | Kokilā Vrata | Pūrṇimā covers 197 of 197 minutes of sāyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 11 Jul | Śiva Śayanotsava | Pūrṇimā covers 61 of 61 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 13 Jul | Aśūnya Śayana Vrata (Āṣāḍha) | Dvitīyā is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 15 Jul | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 22 Jul | Kāmikā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Tue 23 Jul | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 65 of 65 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Wed 24 Jul | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Sun 28 Jul | Madhusravā Tṛtīyā | Tṛtīyā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 29 Jul | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 30 Jul | Nāga Pañcamī | Pañcamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 6 Aug | Putradā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Tue 6 Aug | Dāmodara Dvādaśī | Dvādaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 7 Aug | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 71 of 71 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 10 Aug | Rakṣā Bandhana | The second half of Pūrṇimā covers 551 of 1442 minutes of the day. | Boundary |
| Sat 10 Aug | Ṛṣi Tarpaṇa | Pūrṇimā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 11 Aug | Aśūnya Śayana Vrata | Dvitīyā is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Tue 13 Aug | Kajjalī Tṛtīyā | Tṛtīyā does not reach madhyāhna on either day. | Boundary |
| Tue 13 Aug | Bahulā Caturthī | Caturthī covers 177 of 177 minutes of sāyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 13 Aug | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Thu 15 Aug | Hala Ṣaṣṭhī | Ṣaṣṭhī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 16 Aug | Śītalā Saptamī | Saptamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sat 17 Aug | Janmāṣṭamī | Aṣṭamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Tue 20 Aug | Ajā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Wed 21 Aug | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 78 of 78 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Thu 22 Aug | Aghora Caturdaśī | Caturdaśī covers 78 of 78 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Thu 22 Aug | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Sat 24 Aug | Rudra Vrata | Pratipadā covers 25 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 26 Aug | Haritālikā Vrata | Tṛtīyā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 27 Aug | Gaṇeśa Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 29 Aug | Ṛṣi Pañcamī | Pañcamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 30 Aug | Sūrya Ṣaṣṭhī (Bhādrapada) | Ṣaṣṭhī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sat 31 Aug | Muktābharaṇa Vrata | Saptamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sun 1 Sep | Rādhāṣṭamī | Aṣṭamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 4 Sep | Parivartanī Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Thu 5 Sep | Vāmana Jayantī | Dvādaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 6 Sep | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 86 of 86 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 7 Sep | Ananta Caturdaśī | Caturdaśī covers 158 of 158 minutes of the first three muhūrtas after sunrise. | Determinate |
| Wed 11 Sep | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Fri 13 Sep | Candra Ṣaṣṭhī | Ṣaṣṭhī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Sun 15 Sep | Jitāṣṭamī | Aṣṭamī covers 91 of 91 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sun 15 Sep | Mahālakṣmī Vrata Samāpana | Aṣṭamī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Wed 18 Sep | Indirā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Fri 20 Sep | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 94 of 94 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 21 Sep | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 46 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Boundary |
| Sun 22 Sep | Mahālaya Amāvāsyā | Amāvasyā covers 146 of 146 minutes of aparāhṇa. | Determinate |
| Mon 23 Sep | Navarātrārambha | Pratipadā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 26 Sep | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 30 Sep | Durgā Saptamī | Saptamī covers 46 of 46 minutes of the first muhūrta after sunrise. | Determinate |
| Tue 1 Oct | Mahāṣṭamī | Aṣṭamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 2 Oct | Mahānavamī | Navamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 3 Oct | Vijayā Daśamī | Daśamī with Śravaṇa covers 685 of 685 minutes of the day time. | Determinate |
| Fri 4 Oct | Pāśāṅkuśā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Sat 5 Oct | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 101 of 102 minutes of pradoṣa. | Boundary |
| Fri 11 Oct | Karaka Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Fri 11 Oct | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 14 Oct | Ahoyī Aṣṭamī | Aṣṭamī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Fri 18 Oct | Ramā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Fri 18 Oct | Govatsa Dvādaśī | Dvādaśī covers 109 of 109 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 19 Oct | Yama Dīpadāna | Trayodaśī covers 109 of 109 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sat 19 Oct | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 109 of 109 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sun 20 Oct | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Mon 21 Oct | Naraka Caturdaśī | Caturdaśī covers 110 of 110 minutes of aruṇodaya. | Determinate |
| Mon 21 Oct | Lakṣmī Pūjā | Amāvasyā covers 111 of 111 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Mon 21 Oct | Kālī Pūjā | Amāvasyā covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Tue 22 Oct | Bali Pūjā | Pratipadā covers 111 of 111 minutes of pradoṣa. | Boundary |
| Wed 23 Oct | Govardhana Pūjā | Pratipadā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 23 Oct | Dyūta Pratipad | Pratipadā covers 202 of 202 minutes of pūrvāhṇa. | Determinate |
| Thu 24 Oct | Yama Dvitīyā | Dvitīyā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sat 26 Oct | Nāga Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Sat 26 Oct | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 28 Oct | Sūrya Ṣaṣṭhī | Ṣaṣṭhī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 30 Oct | Gopāṣṭamī | Aṣṭamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 31 Oct | Durgā Navamī | Navamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Fri 1 Nov | Akṣaya Navamī | Navamī covers 169 of 190 minutes of pūrvāhṇa. | Boundary |
| Sun 3 Nov | Prabodhinī Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 4 Nov | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 118 of 118 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Wed 6 Nov | Kārtikī Pūrṇimā | Pūrṇimā covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 6 Nov | Rāsayātrā | Pūrṇimā does not reach niśītha on either day. | Determinate |
| Sat 9 Nov | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī is current at moonrise. | Determinate |
| Sat 16 Nov | Utpannā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Mon 18 Nov | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 124 of 124 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Tue 19 Nov | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Determinate |
| Mon 25 Nov | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Tue 26 Nov | Nāga Pañcamī (Mārgaśīrṣa) | Pañcamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 27 Nov | Campā Ṣaṣṭhī | Ṣaṣṭhī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 27 Nov | Skanda Ṣaṣṭhī | Ṣaṣṭhī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Thu 28 Nov | Mitra Saptamī | Saptamī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Mon 2 Dec | Mokṣadā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Tue 3 Dec | Akhaṇḍa Dvādaśī | Dvādaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Determinate |
| Wed 4 Dec | Śukla Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 0 of 129 minutes of pradoṣa. | Boundary |
| Thu 5 Dec | Dattātreyotpatti | Pūrṇimā covers 129 of 129 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Sun 8 Dec | Saṅkaṣṭa Caturthī | Caturthī does not reach moonrise on either day. | Boundary |
| Mon 16 Dec | Saphalā Ekādaśī | Ekādaśī holds at sunrise. | Determinate |
| Wed 18 Dec | Kṛṣṇa Pradoṣa Vrata | Trayodaśī covers 131 of 131 minutes of pradoṣa. | Determinate |
| Thu 19 Dec | Śivarātri | Caturdaśī covers 48 of 48 minutes of niśītha. | Boundary |
| Wed 25 Dec | Vināyaka Caturthī | Caturthī covers 48 of 48 minutes of madhyāhna. | Boundary |
185 rulings under the 108 rules of the current ruleset, 17 of them on a boundary. A festival that is not listed has no rule in the ruleset yet; it is not being ruled out. Each name opens the working. Read the rules