Ruling · Karaka Caturthī (Karwa Chauth) · 2008

Friday 17 October

Boundaryin Baoding, under the Rashtriya Panchang method. Caturthī reaches moonrise on neither day and the rule does not say what then. Say “contested”.

Decide it for

38°52′ N 115°28′ E · Asia/Shanghai · GeoNames 1816971

The two moonrises

One ghaṭī is 24 minutes. The moonrise is read as disc centre, 31′.

Moonrise of Friday 17 October

Taken. Caturthī reaches neither moonrise; this is the day it falls on.

18:56 moonrise
Caturthī begins 19:09:21
17:4418:0818:3218:5619:2019:4420:08

Absent at moonrise

Moonrise of Saturday 18 October

Caturthī does not hold at moonrise. Not taken.

19:50 moonrise
18:3819:0219:2619:5020:1420:3821:02

Absent at moonrise

Caturthī presentMoonrise, the instant the rule readsThe instant the tithi begins or ends

How it was decided

  1. 01

    Aṅga

    Caturthī runs from 19:09 on Fri 17 Oct to 16:09 on Sat 18 Oct.

    2008-10-17T11:09:22Z → 2008-10-18T08:08:55Z

  2. 02

    Kāla

    Moonrise is at 18:56 on the 17th and 19:50 on the 18th.

    moonrise: disc centre, 31′

  3. 03

    Rule

    Caturthī must be current at moonrise. It is not on the 17th and is not on the 18th.

    Calendar Reform Committee 1955, General Rules for Religious Festivals, p. 104

  4. 04

    Tie-break

    Neither moonrise qualifies. The day the tithi falls on is taken.

    priority: purvaviddha → tithi-day · margin 823 s

  5. 05

    Ruling

    Karaka Caturthī, Baoding, 2008: Friday 17 October.

    confidence: boundary (absent-unstated)

Say it like this

In Baoding, Karaka Caturthī (Karwa Chauth) 2008 falls on Friday 17 October. Caturthī runs from 19:09 on Fri 17 Oct to 16:09 on Sat 18 Oct, and is current at moonrise on neither day.

ahargana.org/baoding/festivals/2008/karaka-chaturthi · pac-rp@2026.1

Who says what

AuthorityKindDate
Ahargaṇa, pac-rpThis rulingFri 17 Oct
Ahargaṇa, classicalDisc centre, no refractionFri 17 Oct
compat-drikpanchangComparison profileFri 17 Oct
No institution has a recorded ruling for Baoding.

Institutional rulings are recorded with a source address, and are never edited to agree.

The rule, as data

/rules/karaka-chaturthi · ruleset 2026.3-draft

Month
Āśvina, amānta
Pakṣa · aṅga
Kṛṣṇa · Caturthī
Kāla
Moonrise
Priority
Pūrvaviddhā
Tie-break
First day
Reference
CRC 1955, p. 104

“K 4 Karaka caturthi (current at moon-rise, if occurs on two successive days, it is to be observed on the first day)” Calendar Reform Committee 1955, General Rules for Religious Festivals, p. 104.

The same rule, elsewhere

Twelve places, west to east. Local clock times.

PlaceCaturthīMoonrise 17thCoveredMoonrise 18thCoveredRuled
Los Angeles04:09 → 01:0920:21holds21:22no17 Oct
Chicago06:09 → 03:0919:46holds20:45no17 Oct
Jersey City07:09 → 04:0919:54holds20:53no17 Oct
Port of Spain07:09 → 04:0920:24holds21:27no17 Oct
London12:09 → 09:0918:56holds19:48no17 Oct
Durban13:09 → 10:0921:27holds22:36no17 Oct
Dubai15:09 → 12:0919:44holds20:44no17 Oct
Delhi16:39 → 13:3919:34holds20:33no17 Oct
Kolkata16:39 → 13:3919:03holds20:03no17 Oct
Singapore19:09 → 16:0921:13holds22:16no17 Oct
Sydney22:09 → 19:0922:14holds23:25no17 Oct
Suva23:09 → 20:0920:40no21:48no17 Oct
Profile · tradition
pac-rp@2026.1 · smarta
Rule
karaka-chaturthi@2026.3-draft
Engine · kernel
0.1.0 · de440 7eef…ea74
Boundary margin
300 s

About Ahargaṇa