Ruling · Bali Pūjā · 1998

Tuesday 20 October

Boundaryin Multan, under the Rashtriya Panchang method. Both evenings qualify and the rule does not say which to take. Say “contested”.

Decide it for

30°12′ N 71°29′ E · Asia/Karachi · GeoNames 1169825

The two evenings

One ghaṭī is 24 minutes. Pradoṣa is 2 muhūrtas after sunset.

Evening of Tuesday 20 October

Taken. Both evenings qualify; the rule is silent, and this one is covered longer.

17:38 sunsetpradoṣa ends 19:20
17:1417:3818:0218:2618:5019:1419:38

102 of 102 minutes covered

Evening of Wednesday 21 October

Qualifies with 4 of 102 minutes. Not taken.

17:37 sunsetpradoṣa ends 19:19
Pratipadā ends 17:41:00
17:1317:3718:0118:2518:4919:1319:37

4 of 102 minutes covered, the first 4

Pratipadā presentPradoṣa, the window the rule readsThe instant the tithi begins or ends

How it was decided

  1. 01

    Aṅga

    Pratipadā runs from 15:09 on Tue 20 Oct to 17:41 on Wed 21 Oct.

    1998-10-20T10:09:23Z → 1998-10-21T12:41:01Z

  2. 02

    Kāla

    Pradoṣa is 2 muhūrtas after sunset: 17:38–19:20 on the 20th, 17:37–19:19 on the 21st.

    pradosha: night-muhurta-1-2 · sunrise and sunset: upper limb, 31′ + 16′

  3. 03

    Rule

    Pratipadā must be present during pradoṣa. It covers 102 of 102 minutes on the 20th and 4 of 102 on the 21st.

    Calendar Reform Committee 1955, General Rules for Religious Festivals, p. 104

  4. 04

    Tie-break

    Both evenings qualify and the rule marks neither. The one covered longer is ruled, as a boundary.

    priority: unstated → greater-coverage · margin 233 s < 300 s

  5. 05

    Ruling

    Bali Pūjā, Multan, 1998: Tuesday 20 October.

    confidence: boundary (margin, tie-break-unstated)

Say it like this

In Multan, Bali Pūjā 1998 falls on Tuesday 20 October. Pratipadā runs from 15:09 on Tue 20 Oct to 17:41 on Wed 21 Oct and covers all of pradoṣa that evening. It also reaches the next evening for 4 minutes; the rule does not say which to take, and the one covered longer is ruled: treat the date as contested. It is 3 min 53 s from a threshold: treat the date as contested.

ahargana.org/multan/festivals/1998/bali-puja · pac-rp@2026.1

Who says what

AuthorityKindDate
Ahargaṇa, pac-rpThis rulingTue 20 Oct
Ahargaṇa, classicalDisc centre, no refractionTue 20 Oct
compat-drikpanchangComparison profileTue 20 Oct
No institution has a recorded ruling for Multan.

Institutional rulings are recorded with a source address, and are never edited to agree.

The rule, as data

/rules/bali-puja · ruleset 2026.3-draft

Month
Kārtika, amānta
Pakṣa · aṅga
Śukla · Pratipadā
Kāla
Pradoṣa
Priority
Unstated
Tie-break
Longer coverage, as a boundary
Reference
CRC 1955, p. 104

“S 1 Govardhana puja, Annakuta [purvaviddha], Balidaityaraja puja (pradosa), Dyuta pratipad (purvahna).” Calendar Reform Committee 1955, General Rules for Religious Festivals, p. 104.

The same rule, elsewhere

Twelve places, west to east. Local clock times.

PlacePratipadāSunset 20thCoveredSunset 21stCoveredRuled
Los Angeles03:09 → 05:4118:13103 min18:110 min20 Oct
Chicago05:09 → 07:4118:01105 min18:000 min20 Oct
Jersey City06:09 → 08:4118:09105 min18:070 min20 Oct
Port of Spain06:09 → 08:4117:4697 min17:460 min20 Oct
London11:09 → 13:4117:57109 min17:550 min20 Oct
Durban12:09 → 14:4118:0988 min18:090 min20 Oct
Dubai14:09 → 16:4117:47100 min17:470 min20 Oct
Delhi15:39 → 18:1117:47101 min17:4625 min20 Oct
Kolkata15:39 → 18:1117:07100 min17:0764 min20 Oct
Singapore18:09 → 20:4118:5295 min18:5195 min21 Oct
Sydney20:09 → 22:4118:120 min18:1387 min21 Oct
Suva22:09 → 00:4118:080 min18:0891 min21 Oct
Profile · tradition
pac-rp@2026.1 · smarta
Rule
bali-puja@2026.3-draft
Engine · kernel
0.1.0 · de440 7eef…ea74
Boundary margin
300 s

About Ahargaṇa